Lightning Strike wrote:Sit wrote:Looks like he's not a popular choice as a top 5 point guard though

Not that I find him a controversial pick, more that I'm amazed that a 40 year old can still hang in the top 5 PG's in the NBA, especially in a position which seems to reward supreme athleticism as of late.
Definitely. Top 5 might be a little overrated (according to some in here) but he is definitely top 10. I think John Stockton would have been top 10 in his last NBA season. Why did I rank him top 5? Because he is the starting point guard on the best team in the NBA and he still brings it every night. His statistics during the playoffs were just really really good as he stepped it up another level - he nearly averaged a triple double against the Warriors.
George7 wrote:Jason Kidd respect

He still
got that something to keep him in the elite.
Exactly

Valor wrote:shadowgrin wrote:The Stealth were rolling towards an NBA Finals and possible championship before Kidd fell to injury. The Stealth crashed out of the playoffs with lack of direction from the most important position on the floor.
The coach was dumb enough not to play Jao Wu.
Ouch Sit, ouch

Jao Wu came on for stretches but was largely ineffective. If he was playing well, he would have earned more minutes.
Lamrock wrote:Glad D-Rose is absent.

D-Rose is still a nobody in this story.

Thierry • wrote:Nice to see Nixon, Steele, Lliach there 
- Nixon is a perennial sixth man of the year candidate. Even from off the bench, he would have been a top 10 point guard. Much better than Bayless

- Steele is one of my favorite generics. If he had more team success with the Nets, I'd rank him a lot higher.
- Lliach is just a beast.

megarover wrote:I am suprised CP3 has been able to keep his place on the top of the list for so long.
CP3 is always an MVP candidate and the Hornets are always near the top of the standings despite his supporting cast being so poorly rated. Before Mark Moore came aboard, the Jazz had 3-4 players who were better than the Hornets' second best player. With that said, Deron Williams, Joe Johnson, Donnell Lawrence are all rated better than Mark Moore. Moore is better than the Jazz starting SF Sidney Hooper but Sidney Hooper is still better than the Hornets' third best player - David West. And then you compare both the Jazz and Hornets and New Orleans have always been consistently winning.
Houndy wrote:Where's Zolio?
All he does is hand out assists.

If he was still in Philly I'd include him for sure but he's been signed by Boston and figured it'd be a waste of a space since he is definitely going to have a poor year - individually and as a team.