Huge argument with a friend.

[Riot]

I'm not saying he is a bad defender, I'm simply saying at times he makes some stupid decsions.

[putodelagoa]

Tony Parker over Arenas, Davis, Marbury and Francis? Are you kidding?

Actually, I'm dead serious. The only guy from your list I might prefer to Parker is Arenas, but he's no PG, not with that assist TO ratio. As for the others, I don't have to think about it twice.

And Matt, Parker may choke in the playoffs, (He didn't in his first year, when he humiliated Payton), but he's still very young, and at least, he makes the playoffs, and stays there long enough to look bad.

[Riot]

He's not PG? He plays PG so he must be a PG. You are just holding him to the sterotypical PG. He doesn't have to be a Jason Kidd or Steve Nash to play PG.

[putodelagoa]

He's not PG? He plays PG so he must be a PG. You are just holding him to the sterotypical PG. He doesn't have to be a Jason Kidd or Steve Nash to play PG.

I guess it's a matter of opinion. And yes, I'm very conservative in the PG department . I'm not saying he's not a great player, I just dont think of him as a floor general, but rather as someone to play off the ball.

[Kirelenko StyleZ]

1. Kidd
2. Iverson
3. Nash
4. Wade
5. Davis
6. Arenas
7. Marbury
8. Francis
9. Bibby
10. Billups

Marbury would be in my top 5 of Scoring PG's though.

Couldn't say it better myself.

[D-MASE]

1.Iversion
2.Kidd
3.Nash
4.Ford
5.Marbary

[The Other Kevin]

Iverson is a SG, no?

[Doobie]

Iverson is a guard . I don't see him as a position , he's just a guard.

[Riot]

He's not PG? He plays PG so he must be a PG. You are just holding him to the sterotypical PG. He doesn't have to be a Jason Kidd or Steve Nash to play PG.

I guess it's a matter of opinion. And yes, I'm very conservative in the PG department . I'm not saying he's not a great player, I just dont think of him as a floor general, but rather as someone to play off the ball.

But what is a floor general? A guy who goes out there and executes his offense? That's excatly what Gilbert Arenas does. Just because he shoots first doesn't mean he isn't a floor general.

[ShAuN]

Marbury, imp isnt a PG. He is, but a shoot first PG. I would NOT say hes in top 5 heres my list:

Kidd
Nash
Arenas/Wade
Hinrich
Ridnour

[J@3]

Do they teach you to quadruple post at .org?

[Riot]

Marbury, imp isnt a PG. He is, but a shoot first PG. I would NOT say hes in top 5 heres my list:

Kidd
Nash
Arenas/Wade
Hinrich
Ridnour

Funny how you say Marbury isn't a point guard because he shoots first and then you put Gilbert Arenas and Dwyane Wade at #3 on your list.