Superstar trade (again?)

Shall I do this trade? If I dont do It this will be my starting 5:
C: Haywood 63
PF:Haislip 58
SF: Carter 86
SG: Mobley 71
PG: Claxton 60

if I will do it this will be my starting 5:
C: Haywood 63
PF: Brand 82
SF:J.R. Smith 60
SG: Mobley 71
PG:Claxton 60

i wouldnt do it!

I would do it I think

It depends on what kind of play you like. Carter is a good all around scorer, he can also make 3's. Brand would be great inside presence on the other hand. However Brand trade would leave you vulnerable at SF.

I'd say that you should go for Brand as it is easier to play in the post.

I'd keep the roster you have now, although I do like Juan Dixon

Not if u dont have a SF, dont do it

i would say both teams are good. Keeping VC would keep the team more fun, but with Brand, you'll have a stronger inside. But i do like you getting Livingstone in that game.

oh

i thought you already have brand,livingston,n'diaye.......

so do this trade!!

Very interesting trade, i would do it