Yeah, I'm still not a fan of the metered alley-oops. By all means make it a thing in the competitive scene, but it should be optional offline.
As for Green-or-Miss, I have misgivings about the concept as well. To echo what I said in our Discord, it sounds like a good idea in theory, appeasing the almighty skill gap and putting us in control instead of at the mercy of RNG. However, there are some drawbacks...
- Precise timing requires minimal latency, which for online play means robust servers and netcode. Unfortunately, this has been a weakness for NBA 2K for years.
- Shooting and shot contest mechanics need to play nice with each other, i.e. be balanced. If a defender can easily take away the Green window just by getting close enough - and thus effectively prevent a make under a Green-or-Miss approach - then you end up with a situation where contested shots are almost always guaranteed misses, which isn't realistic or fun.
- This is an even bigger issue offline, despite the lack of online lag. After all, CPU defenders tend to be better at sticking to their mark than most users, and if they're able to do that, it means the only jumpers you'll hit are very rare open looks, and even then you'll be punished for being slightly off. Turning Green-or-Miss off for lower difficulty levels is a fair compromise, though I think it should go up to All-Star rather than stopping at Pro. Pro can be too easy, whereas All-Star can be that intermediate level that's tough and challenging, while still offering some advantages (like near-perfect releases going in).
Of course, despite all of this playing out before, these concerns will be dismissed as "hating" and a need to "get good", especially by shilling content creators. Then everyone will realise what's happening after a few weeks of the game being out, those same creators will complain as if they weren't dismissing those concerns prior to release. Patches will provide tweaks and then a new system will be implemented next year, before we start the whole cycle all over again.
(And I, having seen it all coming, will break out Dr. Cox's "I told you so" dance.)