Main Site | Forum | Rules | Downloads | Wiki | Features | Podcast

NLSC Forum

Talk about NBA 2K14 here.
Post a reply

Really

Mon Sep 30, 2013 8:56 pm

From the preview gameplay, the Knicks still have those awful-looking sky blue jerseys. I don't even what in the. Is the guy that does the jerseys color blind?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9C0FlINsEFk

I pre-ordered on amazon but I don't know if I can play until I get my hands on some jersey and cyberface ports...

Re: Really

Mon Sep 30, 2013 9:32 pm

SunnyDove, 2k must use NBA colors, its mentioned xxx times, but i full understand you, i always forget about this when i see 2k colors, but this is the true which i cant understand. Why NBA colors looks like non NBA colors- this is the best question. Because we cant argue with 2k using nba palette of colors, they just must- probably some license things. But why in holly hell NBA color looks non accurate to their own real color. Why red is pink, why black is almost grey and why mentioned dark blue is sky blue?

Re: Really

Mon Sep 30, 2013 9:50 pm

it possibly has to do with printing i.e. RGB to CMYK. That's my guess.

Re: Really

Mon Sep 30, 2013 9:55 pm

Ah yeah good point

Re: Really

Tue Oct 01, 2013 1:20 am

There are a lot of variables. Color gamut and luminance are the two main ones as far as PC rendering and displaying that on a monitor, and even the cameras broadcasting a game into a digital format that come through our televisions. For example, NTSC or SMPTE is the old standard definition television and dvd player color gamut, while ITU-R 709 or Rec. 709/BT.709 is the HDTV standard color gamut.

Wide color gamuts are used in photography editing programs for a larger color range as long as the monitor can display them properly. sRGB is the windows standard and what you want to shoot for when calibrating most monitors for the most accurate results when displaying color and luminance.

PC's generally use a luminance of 0-255, while TV's use a luminance of 16-235. I believe this is the main issue, because it was the issue for me. Seeing the Chicago Bulls jersey that looks red on television in real life, and kind of pink in games is really a turn off. My old tv allowed me to change the luminance levels from 0-255 to 16-235 and the jersey looked red again. Not only that, but the cheap seats in the arena's were no longer pitch black and just a dark gray. While it lowered contrast, it brought out some extra details and made the scene look more natural to me.

What's the difference? At a black level of 16, anything under that is clipped and detail is lost. The same goes for the white clipping point of 235 and anything above that. Colors in between get changed as well.

So we have real life jerseys illuminated by lights in an arena that are different for each one, shot by a camera/cameras that have it's own settings and standards for capturing light and color, converted to a format for broadcasting, delivered to us and displayed on our televisions that have different ways of reproducing color and in different formats. Then we have a game with color information from schematics, converted to an image format, rendered in a certain format with different shaders and lighting applied, displayed through our console/pc's to our tv or monitor.

Check these examples and tell me which one you think looks closer to the real thing. I edited one of them.

ImageImage

Re: Really

Tue Oct 01, 2013 3:36 am

Thanks for the all of the info, guys. I never thought about color space / luminance being the main culprit. My line of thought was simply that I've been to Knicks games and I've seen their jerseys for myself and they are so far off in the game that it's mind-boggling. Thank God for mods. I'm pretty sure I used Tha King's Knicks jerseys in 2K13 iirc.

Re: Really

Tue Oct 01, 2013 3:42 am

Their colors are also messed up on console. Take the bulls for example, the paint color is different from the small bulls logos by the paint. For the Heat, the center logo has a different shade of their maroon/burgundy than the paint.

Everyone can put their theories in but that's no excuse. No other game has this issue. Just look at NBA Live, their colors are fine, MADDEN, NHL, MLB The Show.

Colors are part of the the team identity, and they're wrong in NBA 2k and I doubt they can't do anything about it.

All you have to do is buy the official team jersey and see what color it is.
Post a reply