
cykim4 wrote:Huge improvement over your previous Deron Williams in 2k11 and 2k12.
However, he looks too young! That kind of looks like a younger early twenties version of Deron. Also a bit feminine for my taste, and may be a little bit like Damon Stoudemire.
I know it's going to take a while for you to release because that's just ... your style. You come up with a preview, and then release it after couple of weeks. (Honestly, how hard is uploading a completed iff file; it only takes 10 seconds, but it's your work so you can release it anytime you want)
Anyways, huge improvement
bigh0rt wrote:^ You need to go outside, dude. It's patching a video game. This whole 'worship' and 'second tier' and the like just seems silly. Leave it in middle school where it belongs.
cykim4 wrote:I have no idea how AmaroWaade is getting all these fan boys. We are all entitled to our own opinions, so if you think he is the "best," you are entitled to believe so.
However, let me point this out: AmaroWaade, as great as he is, is NOT a household name in making CFs.
The best CF maker prior to 2k13 was UHR028. AmaroWaade was always a second tier CF maker, and honestly people didn't even pay that much attention to his work because there were so many other great CF modders.
Unfortunately, we have a new generation of CF modders who have less experience, and provide lower quality CFs in general. However, due to the "demise" of the great CF modders in the past (including UHR028), now the second tier CF makers like AmaroWaade is being perceived as a "great" one.
Let's be objective. No, he is NOT a "great" one. He is simply a good CF maker with more experience than most of the current new generation of CF makers. That is NOT a reason for why his work should be accepted without criticism.
I think criticism will improve the modder's work in the future. However, I NEVER criticize work that I believe is top-notch quality. Sadly, AmaroWaade has a very long way to reach that status, and until then I think constructive criticism will help him become a better modder.
187 wrote:bigh0rt wrote:^ You need to go outside, dude. It's patching a video game. This whole 'worship' and 'second tier' and the like just seems silly. Leave it in middle school where it belongs.
LOL I never heard of modders as household names.
bigh0rt wrote:^ You need to go outside, dude. It's patching a video game. This whole 'worship' and 'second tier' and the like just seems silly. Leave it in middle school where it belongs.
cykim4 wrote:I have no idea how AmaroWaade is getting all these fan boys. We are all entitled to our own opinions, so if you think he is the "best," you are entitled to believe so.
However, let me point this out: AmaroWaade, as great as he is, is NOT a household name in making CFs.
The best CF maker prior to 2k13 was UHR028. AmaroWaade was always a second tier CF maker, and honestly people didn't even pay that much attention to his work because there were so many other great CF modders.
Unfortunately, we have a new generation of CF modders who have less experience, and provide lower quality CFs in general. However, due to the "demise" of the great CF modders in the past (including UHR028), now the second tier CF makers like AmaroWaade is being perceived as a "great" one.
Let's be objective. No, he is NOT a "great" one. He is simply a good CF maker with more experience than most of the current new generation of CF makers. That is NOT a reason for why his work should be accepted without criticism.
I think criticism will improve the modder's work in the future. However, I NEVER criticize work that I believe is top-notch quality. Sadly, AmaroWaade has a very long way to reach that status, and until then I think constructive criticism will help him become a better modder.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests