Main Site | Forum | Rules | Downloads | Wiki | Features | Podcast

NLSC Forum

Other video games, TV shows, movies, general chit-chat...this is an all-purpose off-topic board where you can talk about anything that doesn't have its own dedicated section.
Post a reply

Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 9:54 am

My goto has always been gametrailers since I can see the game as they review it, and then Kotaku's round up of various reviews, but both have been lacking in terms of quality lately. I do watch Zero Punctuation, but that is rarely for more than entertainment value.

So, any tips? I know most sites do video reviews now, so replacing GT isn't difficult....

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 9:58 am

I don't always trust their reviews but I'm too lazy to look for anything else, so I usually only check reviews from IGN, Gamespot, and a French website called jeuxvideo.fr.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 10:03 am

To be honest, none really. I prefer to rely on word of mouth from fellow gamers.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 10:42 am

So Andrew how many game titles have you played in the past six months excluding FO, NBA Live/2Kx/Jam, WWE, and MK?


el badman wrote:a French website called jeuxvideo.fr.

Well that's certainly reliable. Disgusting.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 10:48 am

I can't think of any offhand. What's your point?

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 11:03 am

Definitely not IGN and GameSpot. I only visit those for upcoming games news.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 3:32 pm

Andrew wrote:What's your point?

To find out other games that you played/acquired based on word of mouth from fellow gamers that might also be of interest since my preference concerning reviews is a bit similar.

I rarely rely on reviews or blogs to determine whether a game is good or bad since the writer's experience with the game might be different with my own experience with the game when I do play it.
However I still read a bit of reviews and gamer opinions if I do stumble across them (instead of actively going to sites for reviews) for some details regarding the game that might affect whether I want a game or not, whether it's generally regarded as a good or terrible game.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 8:24 pm

Play demo.

Watch Quick Look.

Then check worst rated reviews on MetaCritic to see if fundamental problems or if it's merely "not AAA enough."

If too indie, check outofeight.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Thu May 24, 2012 11:50 pm

shadowgrin wrote:To find out other games that you played/acquired based on word of mouth from fellow gamers that might also be of interest since my preference concerning reviews is a bit similar.


Ah, fair enough. Well, thinking back, it probably was actually Fallout 3, which I also played a little at my cousin's place before I ended up getting it. Going the other way, I ended up passing on Duke Nukem Forever after playing the demo and seeing a couple of folks around these parts giving it a "meh" at best.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Fri May 25, 2012 12:52 am

Gameplay videos and developer interview/articles help influence my decision on buying a game. Mostly it's word of mouth and if it is something my friends can and will play with me, or if it is really cheap, I will buy it. I rarely read some journalists review and immediately want a game. For instance, the alpha version of the @dayz mod for Arma 2. I stumbled across a video, watched the entire 6 parts(The Dayz ahead) and was pretty much sold.

Re: Game Reviews, Who do You Trust?

Fri May 25, 2012 5:54 pm

Pdub wrote:developer interview

If the Diablo 3 dev interviews were an indicator I guess you're right Pdub. It's like the guys were about to be executed the following day with the way they conducted that dev diary on youtube.


benji wrote:Then check worst rated reviews on MetaCritic to see if fundamental problems or if it's merely "not AAA

That also. Only thing helpful that MetaCritic does.
Post a reply