What would you prefer? NBA Live 2004 or a super-realistic ga

[Mazzocchi]

I just wanna see your oppinion, what woudl you prefer, NBA Live 2004 or a SUPER-Realistic, Exactally Like The Real Thing, Identical To Real Life, Jersey Phisics, No Glitches or annything, or NBA Live? I dunno about u but am i the only person that says NBA Live 2004? probally lol

[EGarrett]

Theoretically...a perfectly realistic game would be unplayable because none of us are good enough to be in the NBA. Thus...I prefer NBA Live 2004.

[oboeguy]

EGarrett, I respectfully disagree, as the game would not be based on physical abilities. Everything would still come down to the abstraction that is button pushing.

Edit: I prefer NBA Live 2004 too, because, well, a perfect simulation would require too many buttons and so forth. Besides, we have a 3rd person camera, which makes the idea of a "perfect" simulation a little strange.

[pinero]

i prefer a more realistic game, nba live can be close with the right slider adjustments, but when it comes down to it imo espn nba is as close are your gonna get to a realistic sim