Good call, Andrew. I've found (online at least) that "take charge" is pretty useless against star players (heh, just like the real NBA). How many times have I been clearly out of the circle and established only to be run over by TMac or one of his ilk. Heck, Steve Francis has dunked over some of my big guys taking a charge. I know the guy's got mad hops, but come on people!
I'll try the "arms-up" some more.
A propos, how the heck do you stop the dribble penetration of the big stars? It seems like anyone who can wiggle the Freestyle controls fast enough can get to the hole for an easy dunk. OK, maybe I just stink, but any tips on not stinking?
BTW, how fun is it to take a charge when someone (online) tries to post-up at the three point line with a little PG?

Good as a steal... (I learned the hard way so I'm allowed to enjoy this little form of torture)