As far as graphics go, without a doubt, that honor goes to the PC version of Live. Live on the xbox is good (I know, I have it also), but is no where near as detailed, sharp and all-around better looking as the PC version. With everything MAXED and resolutions at 1280x1024, there really isn't much to complain about.
Gameplay is identical to its' console breathen, with one noticeable difference-----the lack of slowdown during transitional play. In the xbox version, there was slowdown when the camera would pan around during gameplay transition (ie..ball being stolen, blocked, etc..). I'm happy to report that the PC version eliminates that problem! Granted you'll need some horses inside your rig to play Live2004 in all its glory! If you''re going to upgrade, Live is one hell of an excuse to do so!
Here are some screenies to tide you over:
Tmac gets the bucket and the foul!
Ben Wallace double teamed:
Kobe takes flight:
The mailman takes the charge:
Carmello Anthony:
Melo faked!:
Yao over Shaq:
Yao vs Shaq
Adjustment in mid air: