Analysis on this signature please!

Check out my signature, I'm trying to work on the red on it, but now I think it looks too dark. I thought before it was too pink/light, but I still can't decide. Ugh shit, the change might be permanent now, since I saved it and closed photoshop, but any feedback would still be appreciated. Maybe there is other things I can work on..

Jersey changes for Manu and Smith would really help.

What is that thing sticking out of Smith's headband?

@ Shadowgrin: I don't think I'm good enough to do jersey switches.. damn if someone could do it for me that would be awesome

@ JT55 hhaha I think thats my bad magnetic lasso tool, I'll try and rework that haha

Magnetic lasso tool. Sounds cool.

I think this is what you're looking for...

I like how you cleaned up Smith, maybe with livingston too, but I don't like how you lightened all of it. The red is too pink now IMO. Hm.. now I just gotta work on that jersey switch... Also in the bottom right corner, right around where the chaser7 part is, the red look darker, but thats only becuz of the building in the backgroud, not becuz I made the colors darker.. I kinda wanna fix that, but I can't really figure it out to make ti look natural when Imake a new adjustment layer, I can give someone the original psd file if they want...

Hmm...that's wierd. I didn't do anything to the colors, just edited Smith's head. Perhaps it's the uploading/saving. I find that sometimes pictures get adjusted after I save them. Like how Manu's head got stretched after I saved it with JPEG.

So you're trying to take out the building near the Chaser7 and make it blend with the background?

thanks for getting back to me. Nah, I'm not trying to get rid of the building, shit I phrased it badly before. Let me try again. Notice in the bottom right corner, it seems darker than the rest of the red. Well I don't know how it happened, but I'd like to fix that.

Also I have a new idea instead of jersey switches, since I don't know how to to, and I don't think anyone would be willing to spend that much time doing it for this sig. If i could get like screenshots of them in clipper jerseys doing similar poses that could be an alternative. Of course I can't do it since I play on Xbox 360.

Oh, yeah. I see it now. Believe it or now, it was only until now I saw it was the city skyline of LA (I assume). I suppose if your not taking anything out then that will be pretty easy to fix.

I have Live on PC, but it's 05, so the graphics aren't as spectacular as I think it would b in 08. And I don't really have that great a record with screenshots (see: my sig).

Haha, damn its ok then. Now I just gotta someone else to view this thread then haha

Pen Tool > Lasso Freaking Tool

Magic Wand>Everything else.

Eraser pwns all, you dolts.

What is that thing sticking out of Smith's headband?

JT you dummy, it's a horn. Haven't you ever seen horns on a person before, sheesh.

but I don't like how you lightened all of it.

Yeah JT, you asshole. You should be ashamed for what you did to the sig.

As if you can honestly tell the difference. I can't, not without checking to see the colour stats for sample pixels.

Eraser pwns all, you dolts.

What is that thing sticking out of Smith's headband?

JT you dummy, it's a horn. Haven't you ever seen horns on a person before, sheesh.

but I don't like how you lightened all of it.

Yeah JT, you asshole. You should be ashamed for what you did to the sig.

What are you talking about? How was I being an asshole there? If you read the whole post, I was trying to be appreciative towarsd JT55. But in all honestly, for me, on my screen it looks significantly different..

And I did use the magnetic lasso tool whoever said earlier... Does anyone want to maybe take screenshots of Ginobili and Smith in Clippers jerseys in those poses or ones similar to those? Or do a jersey switch? Thanks in advance..

He meant JT, not you.

He meant JT, not you.

nah haha, he was mocking me for saying "I don't like what you did.."

Its hard to imply/infer things on the internet I guess.. whatever its not that important..

Yeah, even if he was mocking Chaser, even I couldn't tell the difference (as you can see from my earlier reply). Sorry shadow if I misunderstood.

You are right Chaser, the my edited version of your sig's colors has been altered. It's hard to tell with the naked eye (at least I and probably shadow couldn't tell), but looking at the color stats, it has changed. The Hue in one of the pixels turned from 230 to 0. Again, I didn't do it on purpose, must be the difference made when the computer saves with JPEG.

Oh yes, if you seem to have some trouble with the magnetic lasso tool, just use Paint .

Wait you really can't tell the difference between this without looking at stats:



For me its pretty clear that the bottom version is much lighter..

Perhaps it's the difference between the moniters...and the facct I have a screen on mine. I got almost blinded when I tried to take the thing off, the it's really bright. If I stare really hard at it, I can tell a really subtle difference as the bottom one has some light stripes on it.

And no, I'm not colorblind.