Shooting: analog or button?

just wondering... i just bought a new joystick and i'm curious to know whether it is easier and more effective to shoot with the right analog or with square.

personally, i use buttons

Both. Straight jumpshots (open, catch and shoot), I use button. Layups, dunks, runners, leaners, etc., stick.

Ditto to what shadow said.

Stick.haha. I wanna feel the shot.lol.

I always use the shot stick....always

I only use the button for shooting free throws.

I use button.

I also use both. For jumpshooting, I use button. Everything else, stick. Somehow, I just can't get the jumper right with the stick.

^Try it dude. I never tried using the button. I'm having a hard time. Except on PSP. It doesn't have a right stick.

Stick for everything except open jumpers and all kind of three-pointers. Also I have to admit that I have underestimated shot stick before - never used those stepback or spin jumpers, but recently I found them quite useful