Wat if...

...EA released Live like they are doing it..with out an indepth dynasty mode

And released a seperate game...NBA GM 05 or somethin like that which is just managing ur team in a dynasty- I'm not sure about how Soccer manager games work...do they have a game engine whgere u can play or do u watch ur team?

Which one would u prefer?

I would prefer both. I would get frustrated with a simulation-only game, I prefer to have the choice to be involved in the action (the simulation intervention idea sounds pretty cool). Likewise, I would prefer to have some management duties as well.

They could always do wat fifa did with Soccer GM...the files the 2 games use can be transferred so u can build a team with the GM game then transfer that file into FIFA and play out the games...they could do this with Live!

idiot why would you want seperate?

Manager games tend to be more realistic, and offer a wide range of manager tasks and responsibilities. Some people prefer management games to sports sims. The ability to port saves between the two games would be pretty cool, though I don't think I'd buy both games if they produced two.

Without a shadow of a doubt the greatest series of games ever is the Championship Manager (now Football Manager) series. I reckon 90% of you would think this would be boring but you haven't seen a dynasty mode until you play that. This is probably the reason I have never been happy with a dynasty mode and probably never will be. Oh well I guess those sort of games should be left to the experts.