Before I had a controller with analog (2 years ago) I had been using the d-pad for 5 years and loved it. Then I got the new one and couldn't get it to use the d-pad for movement in 2003. So I just tried to get used to it. 10 or 15 losses in a row later I finally got the hang of it, but still didn't like it. I finally figured out how to use the d-pad (I had to change the 'mode' on my gamepad) and everythign was so much easier.
Edit: and of course I use the analog for freestyle.