Video Card FX5200 or GeForce 4 MX440?

Guys, I really need your help. I'm not planning to buy a high-end video adapter. I just want a card that can display the most decent detail settings in NBA Live 2005.

Please just choose between the two. If you were to buy between these two cards ONLY, which would you choose:

Inno3D GeForce FX5200 64MB 64BIT DDR or
Inno3D GeForce 4 MX440 128MB 64BIT DDR

Which one could display the best detail settings?

Please don't recommend me other video cards. These are the only ones availabe locally that fits my budget.

Thanks.

My specs:

Athlon XP 1.33GHz Palomino(passed NBA Live 2005 requirements)
256MB DDR SDRAM PC2100 (barely passed)
80GB Seagate Barracuda IV 7200 rpm
WIN XP PRO SP2 (passed)
DIRECTX 9.0c
SPEED DUAL ANALOG GAME PAD

dude, i prefer the geforce fxseries 5200, coz it is a lot better the mx series! I am using geforce5200 128bit 128 mb..and the game is so smooth when I play!

go with the fx5200 i dont the mx has pixel shaders which is needed for lighting. maybe if it was a geforce4Ti

@bobcats & Null17,

Thanks. I'm gonna buy the same video card as bobcats'.

dude, i prefer the geforce fxseries 5200, coz it is a lot better the mx series! I am using geforce5200 128bit 128 mb..and the game is so smooth when I play!

Who is that beautiful asian woman there?

dude, i prefer the geforce fxseries 5200, coz it is a lot better the mx series! I am using geforce5200 128bit 128 mb..and the game is so smooth when I play!

Who is that beautiful asian woman there?

you didn't see ? "it's in the game"...

Yea.. Sandara's in the game ahright. mahal ko ang game na to!

@ bobcats: What kind of specs do you have, because I have a GeForce FX 5200 as well. I was hoping it will run it ok since I am getting it today. Thanks!

If given those two, I'd probably go with the FX.

That said, you might want to check online on somewhere like Newegg.com to see if the same money you're looking to spend in a store can get you more online (it probably can).

if u want to kno i can tell u how the fx card is because i will be purchasing this card in the upcoming week since u recommended this card to me