Argh! Disgusting user interface... AGAIN!

Discussion about NBA Live 2004.

Argh! Disgusting user interface... AGAIN!

Postby wangster on Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:25 pm

For how many more years is EA going to punish PC users with a direct port of the console version's UI?????

This is unaccepatable. Granted, I did not have high hopes for it but on my first go of NBA Live for PC, I was extremely disappointed to see the exact same user interface as is used in console versions. It is simply ugly, tedious, and vomit-inducing.

And no, it's not a little thing. User Interface is what makes or breaks a computer program in many cases. Live 2004, fortunately is a basketball simulation game so UI doesn't break the program in this case, but in my opinion it comes pretty close. A user-unfriendly UI that is found in the recent Lives are just not cutting it. You will learn to hate it very quickly as you go through every team by clicking a gazillion time (no scroll-bar), click through a gazillion screens with very little information and freedom on it, and having to resort to clicking tedious buttons while looking at stats and organizing your roster. The fonts are way too big, doesn't fit nearly enough information in one window. And the whole UI is a long shot from being pleasing to the eye. I've asked this many times before, but why can't Live just EXACTLY COPY what the Madden series has done? They have the best sports game UI I've ever seen, with tons of information in one screen, a convenient general panel in every screen for quick navigation, and a nice overall look. If the Madden team isn't so lazy as to just copy the console UI over to the PC every year, why can't Live be also as diligent? I'm not a programmer so I know next to nothing about these processes, but just based on my common sense, it seems very hard to believe that creating a new UI for the PC version is a tremendously difficult and consuming venture, which the Live team makes it seem so. I remember Live 2000 having a very well-organized, only-for-the-PC interface. I was under the impression that new versions of things were supposed to feature improvements in every conceivable category, but... I guess that's just me.

But otherwise, Live 2004 is a GREAT GAME! :D :cool:
User avatar
wangster
 
Posts: 317
Joined: Thu Nov 28, 2002 4:13 pm
Location: BC, Canada

Postby FanOfAll on Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:30 pm

I have to agree with the interface here. However, I didn't like Madden 03's interface...made me use my mouse but I couldnt use my arrow keys. Madden 04's interface was very good however.
FanOfAll
 
Posts: 930
Joined: Tue Oct 28, 2003 11:44 am

Postby bishibashiboy on Thu Nov 13, 2003 4:45 pm

don't have the game yet..but bleh that's retarded.
Why do they have to stick with 640x480 for the UI?
It's SO much better when u don't have to scroll like a madman to see the stats.
Wasn't Live 2000 the last version of the game where you could actually change the resolution of the UI?
bishibashiboy
 
Posts: 633
Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2002 1:02 pm
Location: Vancouver


Return to NBA Live 2004

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests