My rating is 9.75 out of 10: "A must have".
Purely cosmetic things like animations, arenas or cyberfaces aren't important for me. I noticed a great gameplay improvement compared to previous Live games, boosted with the correct use of sliders which will fix many of the problems related here, like blocks, steals or game speed. AI is heavily improved (well, not perfect, but who are

). And game is challenging enough for everyone. What else can you ask for? It's the best basketball game ever, no doubt of it.
The only things I consider as major issues to be fixed are:
- Too few offensive rebounds - sliders don't help.
- Some dynasty mode problems like players lowering dramatically his averages with no reason for it, or the well-known FA sign bug (although I didn't suffered it so far).