by Andrew on Wed Jun 17, 2020 2:08 am
The idea of expanding The Neighborhood into a fully fleshed out game world is intriguing, but also concerning. It suggests a further drift away from a game with core mechanics aimed at hardcore basketball fans, instead targeting gamers in general. And look, I'm not trying to engage in gatekeeping here, because there's too much of that these days. However, it isn't an absurd notion to suggest that an NBA sim should focus on being a simulation of the NBA, and building its wider experiences upon that.
With that being said, The Neighborhood is getting rather stale and uninspired as a game world hub. Events are fairly repetitive, and there's not really any benefit to exploring it apart from general curiosity to see what kind of details are hidden in the back alleys. If they're going more open world with the idea, that's interesting. Potentially very frustrating, as it's already annoying having to run around to different shops and buildings to get cosmetic items or load into MyCOURT, training, and connected modes like 2K Pro-Am and The Rec. Nevertheless, there's also the potential for a more in-depth and dynamic experience in between games; something engaging.
Of course, it would also mean more advertising, more ways of encouraging microtransactions with things to spend VC on. Furthermore, they can re-brand and expand The Neighborhood all they like, but if there continues to be no proper, in-depth matchmaking criteria and options in the Pro-Am modes, no matchmaking and a whole lot of toxicity in The Playground, unbalanced builds, shaky servers, and everything else that's currently dragging down the online experience in NBA 2K, it's going to amount to little more than a fresh coat of paint and cynical cash grab. These bells and whistles look great in trailers and they sucker a lot of people in year after year, only to discover familiar problems with the actual gaming experience. I'm interested to see what they've come up with, but also wary.
As for MyCAREER, being able to play in the G-League again for more than just a portion of the story would be interesting. In fact, if we have different options - different starting points and paths for our MyPLAYER to take - then that would be a great evolution of the concept, especially seeing as how the stories have generally boiled down to the same tale and basically been on rails. There's potential here, too. Of course, once again there are legacy issues with the amount of grinding that's necessary (and push towards buying VC if you want to skip that grind), and if they aren't resolved then it's going to be an all-too familiar experience with a few new (and ultimately superficial) wrinkles.
I'll admit that it's difficult not to approach these things with a certain amount of cynicism after so many years playing basketball games, covering them for the NLSC, and experiencing the hype, hoopla, and yes, misdirection, of many preview seasons. I'd honestly like to get more excited about things. Past disappointments and frustration have taught me to temper expectations though, so that I'm pleasantly surprised by being wrong rather than let down by something that doesn't live up to the marketing hype.