[Q] wrote:My problem with stuff like my team or Ultimate Team or loot boxes is that there are so many possibilities and everything is left up to chance so that the possibility of you getting exactly what you want is much lower than you would think
Whereas what, you have a system when you're at the virtual casino?

It's not like gambling isn't a game of chance as well, in this case with odds set by the developers that can give the house an even bigger advantage than in reality if they so please. With that being said, I agree that the odds should be displayed in MyTEAM (they are in Ultimate Team, now). Even when you buy a real pack of basketball cards, the odds of pulling the rarer inserts are displayed on the pack.
Like Jim Sterling points out, it's a mode where you can use real money but can't cash out real money. As noted, you don't have to use real money and Jim acknowledges that as fair play, as do I. But the fact that you can does make it a predatory mechanic, especially for people who may be recovering gambling addicts (or have addictive personalities in general), or kids who don't know better. There may be some freebies, but it's not designed not to make money. It's not like NBA 2K doesn't have methods of giving away VC and MT, but it's done in the hope that you'll get hooked and buy the former so you can keep tearing open virtual packs. In either case, you can just play with house money, but that's not what they're aiming for.
The problems don't lie with people like us who will say "Yeah, I'm not spending any real money on this" and don't, it's about the people who can't control that impulse who are being targeted. And sure, we can be cynical and say that's on them, a fool and their money are soon parted, and all manner of things that lack empathy while holding everyone else to a higher standard than we hold ourselves. People get into a bad spot in their life and fall victim to vices, and then try to kick their habits. As Jim has pointed out in various videos on the subject of loot boxes and gambling mechanics, a lot of recovering addicts play video games to get that same rush, only without financial stakes or danger to their health. Now there are games that will target that vulnerability and open up avenues for them to spend/lose money in new ways. And yes, capitalism and all that, but the ethics are still rather shady and unconscionable.
Again, I think it's bizarre that we complain about gambling mechanics in any other context in video games, but make excuses for literal gambling. It's no problem for people who abstain from microtransactions, but that's not the only people who play the games, and not who's being targeted here. I think it's scummy to prey on the audience like that, and I don't think the "honesty" of it being actual gambling makes it any less scummy.
Look, I'm not anti-gambling as an activity, or against its representation/depiction in a video game meant for adults. Like I said, it'd be a weird line to draw in a game like GTA with everything else you can do. I think as long as you're not pumping real money into it - especially if that's something you can't afford to do - no harm, no foul. But that is something the game invites and what they're counting on, which is going to target vulnerable people and kids who don't know better; kids who can get their hands on a game they're too young for easier than they can get into a casino, and potentially end up sticking their parents with a huge credit card bill. The fact that it's openly gambling rather than loot boxes and so forth doesn't make it any better than the person who admits they're a jerk, and thinks it justifies them continuing to be a jerk because "at least I'm honest".
If nothing else, and putting all ethical discussions aside, it just strikes me as strange to criticise something in a video game for being
like gambling, but then not criticise
actual gambling in a video game.