Winning Eleven 9 or FIFA 06?

[Ludis]

I have both, and I want to know which you like more.

[Pera]

I never heard of a game named winning eleven 9.
I better google it for pictures.

[streetballaz1]

:shock:
I never heard of a game named winning eleven 9.
I better google it for pictures.

in the USA it's called winning eleven 9.
In Europe it's called Pro evolution soccer 5.

[Fitzy]

PES5 is awesome, but FIFA is better cause you can play fifa 95 or whatever it is

[Anthony15]

Pes5+patching>>>fifa06!

[point-guard]

fifa can never beat winning eleven.

[Pera]

:shock:
I never heard of a game named winning eleven 9.
I better google it for pictures.

in the USA it's called winning eleven 9.
In Europe it's called Pro evolution soccer 5.

OK.I didn't know.

[dada]

I like Fifa more this year.

[Bang]

Winning Eleven. FIFA is a piece of crap. It's arcadey, even though it has improved this year, but still a full 2 games behind winning eleven. (Plays like winning eleven 7 or something!) If you like soccer, then buy Winning Eleven. If you like your soccer games to score unrealistically and run faster than normal, then get FIFA, but then you're not a soccer fan. You're a pinball soccer fan. Whatever that is.

[Jowe]

foozeball?

[Scotty]

Fifa 06 cause i hate the wierd as menu's-i prefer fifa's gameplay better too

[Chris.]

any real football fan would realise that FIFA is way too arcadish and with some adjustments here and there PES will win anyday

[Doug]

Pes 5 just rocks. Better way better then Fifa imo.

[debiler]

PES5 all the way! FIFA is boring and arcady.

[Andreas Dahl]

I prefer FIFA this year much thanks to their new awesome dynasty mode. Actually, almost everything in the game is a big improvement from last year.
I've never liked the PES/WE, and this version is no different. The gameplay feels just the same as previous years and the menus are fucked.

It feels like at least FIFA tried...

[Bang]

What FIFA did is downright copy the system.
Remember that W mashing running system, they changed it to the running system in WE.
Remember that D = instant steal? They changed it to the pressuring system in WE.
I don't get how you would see FIFA is superior gameplay wise because gameplay wise it is inferior to winning eleven or if you weren't too much of a football freak then you'd think it's the same. FIFA is faster and the defense is worse. Also there are less animations (especially with this year's WE, since they added a shit load of new animations).
The interface and the dynasty mode IS better for FIFA, but not the actual gameplay. It's too fast, the defense is lame and the ball physics are a little off. (Although an improvement from the previous FIFAs.)

I still continue to try out the FIFAs when they come out, but they always disappoint me. Actually WC 2006 seems ok so far...but we'll see.

[Chris.]

What FIFA did is downright copy the system.
Remember that W mashing running system, they changed it to the running system in WE.
Remember that D = instant steal? They changed it to the pressuring system in WE.
I don't get how you would see FIFA is superior gameplay wise because gameplay wise it is inferior to winning eleven or if you weren't too much of a football freak then you'd think it's the same. FIFA is faster and the defense is worse. Also there are less animations (especially with this year's WE, since they added a shit load of new animations).
The interface and the dynasty mode IS better for FIFA, but not the actual gameplay. It's too fast, the defense is lame and the ball physics are a little off. (Although an improvement from the previous FIFAs.)

I still continue to try out the FIFAs when they come out, but they always disappoint me. Actually WC 2006 seems ok so far...but we'll see.

well said, couldn't of put it any better
FIFA has learnt that its older games were too aracadish so copied alot from PES thats why they have made such improvments and well the screen menus may not be the best but for me its more about the gameplay than a couple of menus

[kibaxx7]

Pes5+patching>>>fifa06!

Exactly... you can download tons of patches for the league, for example I downloaded the World Cup patch for PES5 (see in the World Cup Games thread I made), you have all the rosters and new countries, the jerseys, the Teamgeist ball, the stadiums, also the referee jerseys, new goal animations, it's just outstanding. You will never find something like that for FIFA.

I have FIFA 2005 and 06, but PES kicks his ass.

[BigKaboom2]

FIFA doesn't even look like soccer. I find it terribly disorienting.

[Srbija]

Pro Evolution is heaps better. The gameplay

[SeekK]

Pro Evolution is heaps better. The gameplay

I agree!

[dada]

Just got me a copy of winning eleven 9 and it isnt bad. I'm reluctant to say I like it more than FIFA because it could just be that I have been playing FIFA for so long and I have become kinda tired of it. I wonder how I'll feel about WE9 after the first 100 or so games. Oh well.

[Silas]

do they have WE9/PES for PC?

[Srbija]

http://pc.ign.com/objects/755/755697.html

There it is.

[Silas]

thanks