Thu May 25, 2006 7:34 am
The idea is good, I like it, but it needs to be well thought out and executed for it to work, otherwise it'll turn into shit.
Thu May 25, 2006 11:42 pm
Qballer wrote:Unrestrict3D wrote:I'm also going to give the thumbs up for the knockout format. I think it'd put pressure on everyone to do their absolute best and it'd make for some good competition.
I don't know... I think if it's knockout, we need a good, diverse group of judges.
That's true. Again, I'm in favor of the knockout format, but I think Qballer raises a good point that these judges need to be diverse and at least artistically aware rather than just, "sweet graphics!" As we've seen several times in the Sig League, there's not a very strong correlation between public voting and artist voting.
Fri May 26, 2006 5:04 am
cyanide wrote:Qballer wrote:Unrestrict3D wrote:I'm also going to give the thumbs up for the knockout format. I think it'd put pressure on everyone to do their absolute best and it'd make for some good competition.
I don't know... I think if it's knockout, we need a good, diverse group of judges.
That's true. Again, I'm in favor of the knockout format, but I think Qballer raises a good point that these judges need to be diverse and at least artistically aware rather than just, "sweet graphics!" As we've seen several times in the Sig League, there's not a very strong correlation between public voting and artist voting.
yeah I tihnk this issue came up (at least for me) in the slg league when no one really liked your Amare sig, which I thought had the best creativity & use of color, while others bashed it for looking too much like an ad.
Thu Jun 01, 2006 8:37 am
did this die 