Need Feedback ASAP from Anyone

[JaoSming]

Hey boys, I need some feedback ASAP

which looks better, the white sky which is original sky that was photographed...overcast day....the 2nd sky is PSed in

which looks better. I need answers ASAP

[Lamrock]

Definitely the non-photoshopped one

[J@3]

Yeah the non-photoshopped one. Just because the clouds take up the entire sky in the second one. If you could find a picture of a sky from that perspective and use it it'd look good, but as it stands just using the cloud filter makes it look like the wedding is about to be invaded by clouds.

[Patr1ck]

If you changed the clouds to look real or just have a blue sky, the second one would be ok.

[JaoSming]

thanks boys. The gal figured out how to mess with the sky parts through the trees after having waaaay too much fun with Content Aware Fill with the park rangers. (BTW, Resynthesizer has been out in GIMP for years?!1 WTF)

Unfortunately I didnt see any of the sky edits until I posted this to help prove my point, so I may never get married. But I'm awake sick and she is sleeping soundly, so, Karma?

She spent nearly all day fixing the photos from that day.....then the 2nd half of the day doing those skies. I'll break it to her in the AM.


Thanks again In the clutch

[Patr1ck]

Goosebumps?

[Lean]

Too late for a reply though. I say the Clouds filter from Photoshop doesn't really provide the realistic look for clouds.

[JaoSming]

Goosebumps?

upset stomach


thanks again guys