by Silas on Tue Sep 18, 2007 5:36 am
I've done a lot of thinking about the existence and I've come to this conclusion, it can't exist.
And heres why:
It is widely believed by nearly every major religion in the world, that upon death, people who follow the practices of their religion will proceed to heaven, or some other form of perfection or paradise. Though each religion’s afterlife is different, for instance if you follow the practices of Catholicism, you will go to the catholic form of heaven, but not the Baptist heaven, or the Mormon heaven, or any other religion’s heaven. This means that each religion must have a separate form of heaven, or heaven cannot exist at all.
The Miriam-Webster dictionary defines heaven as “a place of supreme happiness” and paradise as “a place or state of bliss”. So, heaven is a place where reality defies itself – a place where everything is completely perfect. Despite the different religion’s qualifications for arriving at this utopia, the end result is relatively the same, perfection.
A human thought is like a fingerprint. Each person’s notion of something that is intangible is unique. Identity Theory states that one person’s perception of a certain thing is different than another’s. That fact is what gives each human being their individual identity. So based on this statement, each person’s idea of perfection would be different, and since heaven is a place of perfection, each person’s idea of heaven would also be different, meaning that within each religion’s form of heaven, each individual person possesses their own unique heaven.
If everyone possesses a different view of heaven, how can there be only one form of heaven? If that sole form of heaven is perfect for one person, it cannot be perfect for another. Suppose both person a and person b follow the rules of their religion and proceed to heaven. Person a has only one request for perfection, and that is a world where person b does not exist, and since both person a and person b are going to heaven that is impossible. This fallacy alone prevents a notion of a sole heaven from being possible.
But following the above logic, even unique heavens still could not be possible. Since person a and person b have unique notions of heaven, they would each have to have their own unique heaven. But what if person a had only one form of perfection, and that was a unified heaven, where everyone lived together and sacrificed a small portion of their perfection for a larger, unified afterlife. This would make it impossible for there to be multiple forms of heaven.
So heaven, as a unified world, cannot exist, and neither can heaven as many separate worlds. Heaven must either be a place that is not completely perfect, or it cannot exist at all. And since heaven is a place, by definition, of utter perfection, it cannot be imperfect. Therefore, heaven cannot exist at all.