Blogtable: Is it time for Bulls to trade Rose?I'd have to agree with the consensus. It's not that trading Rose is unimaginable; it's that it isn't an absolute must (yet), and more importantly, doing so is easier said than done.
Forget GarPax's track record in getting good value in trades for a moment. Generally speaking, it's tough for any team to get fair value when trading star players, and that goes for players who are far better and far healthier than Rose. Just look at pretty much any Hall of Famer, or future Hall of Famer, that's been traded. Now throw in the fact that Rose hasn't played his best basketball in four years, and he's had a bunch of injuries, and it's even harder to get a good trade that won't involve taking on an even worse contract.
If you're going to trade one of your key players, ideally you want to either make your team better immediately, or set things up so you have ways of making your team better in the near future (shed bad contracts, clear space, remove a logjam, and so on). As it stands, I don't think you can do either in trading Rose. I can't imagine many (if any) teams would be seriously considering the risk, and certainly not to the extent where they'd give up non-guaranteed lottery picks or quality players in return. And again, because of his big contract, the Bulls would likely have to take on some even worse deals to get the deal done.
Sticking with Rose, trying to make it work, and hoping for the best, is really all they can do for now. Short of some GM losing their mind and offering up one of the best players in the league for him, trading him just isn't viable, unless you're willing to make a lateral move, or make it difficult to improve the roster in the name of riding him out of town on a rail. As noted in the article though, he becomes an expiring contract next year. And, if things continue to sour with Rose, and Butler keeps getting better, and teams have offers that either make the Bulls better, or put them in a position to get better...well, then you can re-evaluate the possibility, because his expiring contract makes him a little more appealing. For now, though, their hands are tied.