Andrew wrote:shadowgrin wrote:Until Thibs gets his own hardware as a head coach, Carlisle > Thibs. Unlike with players I think the 'ring' argument can be applied to coaches.
I don't know, it still comes down to the team that's assembled.
Thibs is definitely a great coach, especially a great defense coach, but I think Carisle is somewhat underrated and due to his experience and achievements I'd give Carisle the nod. But Thibs is only at the beginning of his head coach career, so he still has a lot of time to climb the ladder.
Carisle is underrated as a defensive coach imho. The way he mixes in the zone defense helped the Mavs to win the title.