Badger wrote:from wat i remember it was a rookie game before, it was east rookie and west rookie.
That's correct, although the problem was that some years you'd have trouble finding 16 decent rookies, so game wouldn't be that high quality & guns like Eddie Jones would dominate.
I agree with others that Rook/Soph East vs West game would be the best, once this Shaq vs Chuck TNT gimmick has run its course. I'd make it 4/5 rooks & 4/5 sophs per team, so it's not 8 sophs, 2 rooks since sophomores tend to take the leap in their 2nd year.