All-Star Voting Begins

Why are so many people voting for Rose? He's not very good.

West:
C - Andrew Bynum
PF - Dirk Nowitzki
SF - Carmelo Anthony
SG - Kobe Bryant
PG - Chris Paul

East:
C - Dwight Howard
PF - Chris Bosh
SF - LeBron James
SG - Dwyane Wade
PG - Brandon Jennings

East
C-Shaq
F-Lebron James
F-Josh Smith
G-Dwayne Wade
G-Joe Johnson

West
C-Andris Biedrins
F-Dirk Nowitzki
F-Carmelo Anthony
G-Kobe Bryant
G-Steve Nash

Write-in: Yi Jianlian Let's get him in this year

Why are so many people voting for Rose? He's not very good.

Agreed. He was merely an average starting point guard last year, and is having a sophomore slump. He may be the Brooke Shields of big men but Brook Lopez should have won the award last season. I didn't really understand why he was hyped so much in the first place though. That block in last year's playoffs was nifty though

For me, it's a strictly homerish vote.

Oh I get it with you, but not the 4 or 5 people who followed

Also homerish from me. I forgot to mention my write-ins for Joakim Noah and Aaron Gray.

Also homerish from me. I forgot to mention my write-ins for Joakim Noah and Aaron Gray.

Same, I did a write-in for Noah.

Noah would be my write-in, as he actually deserves to make the game. He and Kaman should have made the ballot.

East
C Dwight Howard
PF Chris Bosh
SF LeBron James
SG Dwyane Wade
PG Rajon Rondo

West
C Andrew Bynum
PF Dirk Nowitzki
SF Kevin Durant
SG Kobe Bryant
PG Deron Williams

Write in: Will Bynum

It kind of bugs me that Joakim Noah and Ben Wallace didn't make this ballot, but Brad Miller and Rasheed Wallace did. I mean, none of those guys are going to the game, but it's still rather lame.

It's somewhat understandable with Noah, as he hasn't really been terrific until this year. I think he's in with a genuine shot at the coach's vote if he continues to lead the league in rebounding. And Ben Wallace has been rubbish the last couple of years. Brad Miller has been a consistent double-figure scorer throughout his career, which has probably kept him on the ballot. And Rasheed Wallace is still an impact player, plus he's in Beantown.

Chris Kaman's exclusion is totally stupid.

It's somewhat understandable with Noah, as he hasn't really been terrific until this year.

You mean last year.

WEST:

Carmelo Anthony
Kevin Durant
Steve Nash
Brandon Roy
Amare Stoudemire

EAST:

Charlie Villanueva
LeBron James
Vince Carter
Dwyane Wade
Dwight Howard


Brandon Roy selection was slightly biased, even though he's having a great season anyway.

WEST:

C: Stoudamire
PF: Dirk Nowitzki
SF: Shawn Marion
SG: Jason Terry
PG: Chauncey Billups

EAST:

C: Howard
PF: Jermaine Oneal
SF: Carter
SG: Wade
PG: Harris

Most of the West are biased except for Dirk, who I think might be a lock in the All-Star.

Write-in: Jason Kidd or Darko Milicic

It's somewhat understandable with Noah, as he hasn't really been terrific until this year.

You mean last year.

I do not. I mean when he's been able to string 36 minutes together without going into cardiac arrest.

Of course a fair vote for me(GO BULLS!!!!!!!!!!!)

East
Derrick Rose
Ben Gordon
Luol Deng
Lebron James
Dwight Howard

West
Chris Paul
T-Mac
Carmelo Anthony
LaMarcus Aldridge
Amar'e Stoudamire

Write In - Tyrus Thomas!!!!

and voted another one
including Kobe insted of T-Mac and Hinrich,Miller instead of Gordon,Howard

I do not. I mean when he's been able to string 36 minutes together without going into cardiac arrest.

You said he hasn't been terrific until this year. But he was terrific last year. He was probably the Bulls most valuable player during the regular season and the playoffs.

EAST:

Optional: Joel Anthony

At least someone knows about real NBA ball in this thread.

With Yao being out, who will the numerous Chinese fans vote for?
Please not Yi.

He may be the Brooke Shields of big men

Nice find.
I lold at this one. I love KG's expression and dialogue in the 4th panel.
lol also at Rashard's dunk idea.

I do not. I mean when he's been able to string 36 minutes together without going into cardiac arrest.

You said he hasn't been terrific until this year. But he was terrific last year. He was probably the Bulls most valuable player during the regular season and the playoffs.

I'm with you on the playoffs 100%, although Ben Gordon would have given him a run for his money as playoff MVP. But Noah's lack of conditioning kept him off the floor for 24 minutes every game of the regular season. So he wasn't able to make the same impact that he has this year. This past off-season, he has obviously worked his penis off and got himself into much better shape (throwing away the bong has evidently helped). And because of that, he's managed to keep the Bulls with a reasonable record despite the rest of the team (save Deng and to a lesser extent Hinrich and Miller) playing like arse.

To get back to the semantics argument, yes, when he was on the court last year, Joakim Noah was terrific. But he just wasn't on the court enough. I don't know if there's a stat that shows what the Bulls' record would have been had Noah played 36 minutes every game, but I'm sure it would have netted the Bulls an extra win or 3 or 4.

At the end of the day, I'm hoping that the numbers he's posted this year will be enough to get him an All-Star spot, because he deserves it. But then there's also been a great improvement in the other East Centres. Lopez is even better than he was a year ago, but the Nets are disgusting right now, so he's probably out. Al Horford has been very good on a very good Atlanta team. Andrew Bogut has come on strong after a weak first couple of games. And Roy Hibbert is probably close to Most Improved Player on a not awful Indiana team. Throw in the out of position David Lee and Andrea Bargnani and finally Shaq, who can't really not make the All-Star team.

Dwight Howard gets the start, and reserve Centre is likely between Noah, Bogut, Horford, Lopez and Hibbert.

East

C: Shaquille O'Neal
F: Anderson Varejao
F: LeBron James
G: Vince Carter
G: Mo Williams

West

C: Mehment Okur
F: Dirk Nowitzki
F: Carmelo Anthony
G: Brandon Roy
G: Steve Nash

Optional Write-In: Shane Battier