top 5

[Amphatoast]

What are you guys opinions on the top 5 players at each position? There are a few that are obvious picks ( shaq, KG, Kobe, t-mac, etc.) but when you get to 3,4,5 its really hard to tell who to pick at certain positions.

[Andrew]

My picks:

Centres:
1. Shaq
2. Brad Miller
3. Nesterovic
4. Kandi
5. Ilgauskas

Power Forwards:
1. Duncan
2. KG
3. Nowitzki
4. Webber
5. Mailman

Small Forwards:
1. Marion
2. Mashburn
3. Jamison
4. Artest
5. Peja

Shooting Guards:
1. Kobe
2. T-Mac
3. Pierce
4. Finley
5. EJ

Point Guards:
1. Kidd
2. GP
3. Steve Nash
4. Parker
5. Davis

[wangster]

C- 1.Shaq 2.Ben Wallace 3.Brad Miller 4.Yao Ming 5.Ilgauskas
PF - 1.Duncan 2.Garnett 3.Nowitzki 4.Jermaine O'neal 5.Brand
SF - 1.Carter(no injury) 2.Marion 3.Mashburn 4.Stojakovic 5.Walker
SG - 1.Kobe 2.McGrady 3.Iverson 4.Ray Allen 5.Pierce
PG - 1.Kidd 2.Marbury 3.Nash 4.Payton 5.Francis

[Andrew]

Forgot about Carter, Marbury and Francis.

My revised Small Forwards:
1. Carter
2. Marion
3. Mashburn
4. Jamison
5. Artest

My revised Point Guards:
1. Kidd
2. Payton
3. Marbury
4. Francis
5. Nash

[Shep]

C
1. S.O'Neal
2. Z.Ilgauskas
3. T.Ratliff
4. K.Thomas
5. Y.Ming

PF
1. K.Garnett
2. T.Duncan
3. C.Webber
4. D.Nowitzki
5. E.Brand

SF
1. S.Marion
2. J.Mashburn
3. A.Jamison
4. J. Stackhouse
5. R.Artest

SG
1. T.McGrady
2. K.Bryant
3. A.Iverson
4. P.Pierce
5. M.Jordan

PG
1. G.Payton
2. J.Kidd
3. S.Marbury
4. S.Francis
5. S.Cassell

Overall
1. K.Garnett
2. T.Duncan
3. T.McGrady
4. S.O'Neal
5. K.Bryant

[Swoosh]

C- 1. Shaq 2. Yao 3. Brad Miller 4. Kandiman 5. Mourning(if he can return to old form, otherwise Ilgauskas)
PF - 1. TD 2. KG 3. C-Webb 4. Brand 5. J. O'neal(four old times sake i could say Malone but his roll will now diminish)
SF - 1. Nowitzki 2. Marion 3. G. Hill(when not injured ) 4. Mash 5.Odom
SG - 1. T-mac 2. Kobe 3. AI 4. Vince 5. Pierce/Allen
PG - 1. Marbury 2. Kidd 3. Payton 4. Davis 5. Francis

[.]

Centers:

1-Shaquille O´Neal
2-Ben Wallace
3-Zydrunas Ilgauskas
4-Theo Ratliff
5-Brad Miller

Power Forwards:

1-Tim Duncan
2-Kevin Garnett
3-Dirk Nowitzki
4-Chris Webber
5-Jermaine O´Neal

Small Forwards:

1-Shawn Marion
2-Jamal Mashburn
3-Peja Stojakovic
4-Antoine Walker
5-Antawn Jamison

Shooting Guards:

1-Kobe Bryant
2-Tracy McGrady
3-Allen Iverson
4-Paul Pierce
5-Ray Allen

Point Guards:

1-Jason Kidd
2-Steve Francis
3-Gary Payton
4-Stephon Marbury
5-Steve Nash

[Matt]

C Shaq.............not enough legit C to fill in the rest
PF Garnett, Duncan, B Wallace, C Webber, Brand
SF Marion, Nowitzki, Mash, Jamison, Carter
SG Kobe, AI, T-Mac, Pierce, R Allen
PG Payton, Kidd, Francis, Steph, Bibby

[TRUball]

Center:

1-Shaquille O´Neal
2-Ben Wallace
3-Zydrunas Ilgauskas
4-Brad Miller
5-Theo Ratliff

PF

1-Tim Duncan
2-Kevin Garnett
3-Dirk Nowitzki
4-Chris Webber
5-Jermaine O´Neal

SF
1-Shawn Marion
2-Jamal Mashburn
3-Vince Carter
4-Lamar Odom
5-Peja

SG
1-Kobe
2-T-Mac
3-Iverson
4-Pierce
5-Ray Allen

PG
1-Jason Kidd
2-Steve Francis
3-Marbury
4-Nash
5-Payton

[Scary Hedo]

Centers:

1-Shaquille O'Neal
2-Ben Wallace
3-Zydrunas Ilgauskas
4-Brad Miller
5-Alonzo Mourning

Power Forwards:

1-Tim Duncan
2-Kevin Garnett
3-Dirk Nowitzki
4-Chris Webber
5-Jermaine O'Neal

Small Forwards:

1-Vince Carter
2-Shawn Marion
3-Peja Stojakovic
4-Jamal Mashburn
5-Antawn Jamison

Shooting Guards:

1-Tracy McGrady
2-Kobe Bryant
3-Allen Iverson
4-Paul Pierce
5-Ray Allen

Point Guards:

1-Jason Kidd
2-Stephon Marbury
3-Steve Francis
4-Gary Payton
5-Steve Nash

[Amphatoast]

My picks:

Shooting Guards:
1. Kobe
2. T-Mac
3. Pierce
4. Finley
5. EJ

Just wondering, why AI ain't there? Mistake? If not why?

And what about Yao? Kandiman>Yao?

[Andrew]

My memory's really letting me down in this thread.

My revised Shooting Guards:
1. Kobe
2. Iverson
3. T-Mac
4. Pierce
5. Finley

[Swoosh]

I totally forgot to put Ben Wallace with my PF's (he IS a pf playin at C), put him in there somewhere in stead of c-webb

[GForce11]

C - S.O'Neal, Yao, Ilgauskas, B.Miller, Magloire
PF - Duncan, Garnett, Nowitzki, Webber, Malone
SF - Marion, Mashburn, Stojakovic, A.Walker, R. Lewis
SG - McGrady, Bryant, Iverson, Pierce, Carter.
PG - Kidd, Marbury, Payton, B.Davis, Nash.

[Scary Hedo]

and where is Ben Wallace Andrew?? or do you think he doesn't belong in your list??

[LeBron James]

centers-

1.alonzo mourning
2.ben wallace
3.brad miller
4.mutombo
5.rasho


Power forwards:
1.TimMMMMMM"UNSTOPABLE" DUNCAN!!!!!!!
2.dirk
3.webber
4.malone
5.elton brand


Small Forwards:
1.VINCEEEEEE CARTERRRR!
2.peja
3.mashburn
4.antawn
5.stack


Shooting Guards:
1.allen iverson
2.paul pierce
3.ray allen
4.finley
5.jordan(y) he is not playing but.


Point Guards:
1.JASOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNNNN KIDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD!
2.gary payton
3.franchise
4.nash
5.bibby

[Bourbon]

Centers
1. Shaquille O'Neal
2. Yao Ming
3. Ben Wallace
4. Zydrunas Ilgauskas
5. Brad Miller

Power Forwards
1. Tim Duncan
2. Dirk Nowitzki
3. Chris Webber
4. Jermaine O'Neal
5. Elton Brand

Small Forwards
1. Kevin Garnett
2. Vince Carter
3. Shawn Marion
4. Antawn Jamison
5. Jamal Mashburn

Shooting Guars
1. Kobe Bryant
2. Tracy McGrady
3. Allen Iverson
4. Paul Pierce
5. Ray Allen

Point Guards
1. Jason Kidd
2. Gary Payton
3. Stephon Marbury
4. Steve Francis
5. Steve Nash

[Jackal]

centers-

1.alonzo mourning
2.ben wallace
3.brad miller
4.mutombo
5.rasho

You are one of the VERY few people that would put another Center ahead of Shaq, I dont see any other Center averaging 27.5 ppg, 11.1 rpg, 3.1 apg and 2.31 bpg.
Anyways, its your opinion .

The list:

Center:
1) Shaq
2) Ilgauskus
3) Zo (Big IF)
4) Miller
5) Curry (His play against Shaq was amazing when the Bulls met the Lakers )

Power Forward:
1) Duncan
2) O'Neal
3) Malone
4) Wallace
5) Stoudemire (As Shaq said: I've seen the future of the NBA, His name is Amare Stoudemire.)

Small Forward:
1) Garnett
2) Nowitzki
3) Marion
4) Carter
5) Jamison

Shooting Guard:
1) Bryant
2) T-Mac
3) Iverson
4) Pierce
5) Ricky Davis

Point Guard:
1) Jason Kidd
2) Stephon Marbury
3) Steve Francis
4) Baron Davis
5) Gary Payton

[.]

oh man... Vin Diesel/Jason Duncan.....I also hate some players, but I have to admitt that some of them have game, and I even listed them in my post....but how dare you put Shaq and Kobe out?.....

[emadhn15]

Center

1-Shaq
2-Mourning
3-Mutombo
4-Ilgauskas
5-Yao Ming

Power Foward

1- KG
2- TD
3- Nowitzki
4- Webber
5- Jermaine O'neal

Small Foward

1- Vince
2- Jamison
3- Marion
4- Stackhouse
5- Peja

Shooting Guard

1- KB
2- TMAC
3- Iverson
4- Pierce
5- Melo????

Point Guard

1- Jason Kidd
2- Steve Francis
3- Strabury
4- Baron Davis
5- Payton

[Jackal]

oh man... Vin Diesel/Jason Duncan.....I also hate some players, but I have to admitt that some of them have game, and I even listed them in my post....but how dare you put Shaq and Kobe out?.....

Ignorance Ignorance and Ignorance that's why he dares, Its amazing he didnt put Vlade Divac in his top 5 .

[LeBron James]

oh man... Vin Diesel/Jason Duncan.....I also hate some players, but I have to admitt that some of them have game, and I even listed them in my post....but how dare you put Shaq and Kobe out?.....

Ignorance Ignorance and Ignorance that's why he dares, Its amazing he didnt put Vlade Divac in his top 5 .

well thats my opinion kobe 4mvp but shaq isnt my top5 he is 7 or 8.
i know he is very good player.he is unstopable but he wasnt 2002/03,injurie did his job,lakers fall behind in start of season.

[.]

you really think that Nesterovic and Michael Finley are better then Shaq and Kobe? what kind of bball have you been *watching?*

know he is very good player.he is unstopable but he wasnt 2002/03,injurie did his job,lakers fall behind in start of season.

they recoverd from that didnt they? but Carter was injured aswell and the Raptors didnt recoverd from that record...so it doesnt make any sense....I know U dont like Them because they defeated the Spurs 3 years in a row....so there is no need for some lame excuses

[Jackal]

well thats my opinion kobe 4mvp but shaq isnt my top5 he is 7 or 8.
i know he is very good player.he is unstopable but he wasnt 2002/03,injurie did his job,lakers fall behind in start of season.

Just for the SAKE of asking, could you name me the 8 better players than Shaq AT HIS POSITION (not KIDD)

I know U dont like Them because they defeated the Spurs 3 years in a row....so there is no need for some lame excuses

Dont forget they swept the Nets...4 to....NUTHING 4-0

[air gordon]

geez cut the guy some slack. the question is asking your own personal opinion of the top 5 at each position. we all our entitled to our own opinion

i didn't know you had to include certain players