volsey wrote:It is an Overall attribute after all. If it did disregard a players lesser attributes it wouldn't really serve the purpose of an overall attribute right? I always thought in addition to the regular OFF and DEF quick-glance attributes a SKILL attribute or something along those lines would be useful. But now I think the Signature Skill icons will do an even better job.
True, though ratings such as Dunking needn't have the same weight as shooting or rebounding ratings. A player's ability to dunk, their frequency of dunking and the creativity of their dunks shouldn't carry too much weight when calculating the overall. It should arguably be the same for all athletic ratings, as they're not a skill per se. At the end of the day, the importance of overall ratings is somewhat overblown and they usually coming out looking accurate enough, so there is way too much fuss over them. That said, they could be calculated a little better to account for the situations I mentioned before.