Haven't seen this thread before. Well, here goes...
[MY PLAYER]
-Taking a charge is way too difficult. You have to be rooted to the spot for like five seconds and if the ball handler runs full speed at you then you get the charge, but also you get injured quite frequently.
-Someone define "Bad Steal Attempt" please. When I successfully tap the ball away, I think that's a GOOD steal attempt.
-Open threes are NOT an example of "Bad Shot Selection" when you have your three-point rating MAXED OUT at 99. or at least they should be.
-My 20ppg, 4apg, 3rpg point guard still has a 53 overall rating, yet starts over Jason Kidd and Rodrigue Beaubois.
-CPU players do not foul out. I had Roy Hibbert pick up NINE fouls against me and he still didn't leave the game. Also when someone "fouls out" (or not), the team-foul counter goes up by like ten. Indiana apparently had 46 team fouls by the end of the game.
-The "Hold the Ball Too Long" thing is fucking retarded. As a point guard, if I hold/dribble the ball for ten seconds without passing, it deducts like half a bar off the teammate grade. Meanwhile, in my other My Player (a 7'5 center in New York) Chauncey Billups decides to wind the shot clock down to 4 EVERY SINGLE POSSESSION.
-Chauncey Billups is a total moron and can't/won't recognize when there is a perfect screen or an open man, but definitely shoots well. He also doesn't seem to think that Amar'e Stoudemire exists.
-RONNY TURIAF CHUCKED FIVE THREES IN ONE GAME AND MADE FOUR OF THEM.
-There are a lot of guys with no heads and white arms (although that's probably the fault of the patch I'm using, still funny though to see a headless Derrick Williams dunk over people.)
-WHY THE FUCK IS JONNY FLYNN SO FUCKING GOOD?
-There are way too many ball hoggers and shot chuckers. Their teammate ratings would all be D's for sure.
-Probably the most annoying glitch of them all: My point guard has a 99 three-point rating, a 96 mid-range rating and a 90 inside scoring rating. I am extremely accurate with my timing, and rarely take heavily contested shots. My season average is 19% from downtown What I noticed recently is that I can start a game shooting well from outside, but after about three minutes in the game, even the most perfectly launched threes just simply refuse to fall.

This happens every time a new game/half starts, or when you get subbed in. I have no idea why this is happening, as my stamina rating is around 80-90, and it likely isn't part of the problem.
[ASSOCIATION]
I don't think association mode has any of the problems I listed here (except the white arm no head thing and the take charge problems.)
The only bugs I have a problem in association mode are:
-The stupid trades: (ex: James Harden + Serge Ibaka for Ramon Sessions + next year's 2nd round pick)
-Erik Spoelstra joined the Bulls once, and Joel Anthony followed.
-The awesomeness of the T-Wolves (EXCEPT for Love). Kevin Love sucks, I don't think he's ever got a double-double against me. Darko, Johnson, Beasley, and Flynn all play better in game play. They also blew out the Heat 120-something to 90.

I also tried lowering their ratings: Darko to 55, Flynn to 65. Flynn still averages 16/8.
-Athletic guards really do rule the league after about five years. Top five guards in 2016 in a sim association: Derrick Rose (94), Jonny Flynn
holy shit. (92), Brandon Jennings (92), John Wall (90), Deron Williams (87). Westbrook is somewhere there too, but he's out for the season with an ACL tear.
-Dwight Howard all of a sudden gets injury-plagued. He must have been hit by like ten different injuries and missed like half of (I think) the 2013 season. Had he played the whole season, he would've been MVP for sure. (30ppg, 14rpg.)
Wow.
I hope for you guys' sake 2k12 fixes some of this. I'm good with 2k11 for now, I don't have a lot of $$$$$$ to spend on games. Until I buy a new game, I'll just try to find ways to get around some of this shit.